Magic Sushi 2

Magic Sushi 2
562 Keenleyside St
204-415-7922

For years, I drove by Magic Sushi 2 and had no clue what the restaurant’s name was.  Their “all you can eat” sign dominates the frontage where I thought All You Can Eat was actually the name. 

I used to be leery about all you can eat sushi houses since they usually come with tons of rice and very little fish.  I found some genuinely good all you can eat places down Pembina so I have renewed confidence to enter Magic. 

The outside of the building looks a bit dumpy but I find out that’s the nice part; the inside looks like an absolute dump.  I love eating burgers or fish & chips at holes-in-the-wall but sushi is supposed to be a delicate and elegant food; there’s nothing delicate or elegant about Magic.  I should get over it since I’m here for the food and good food makes up for ambiance. 

Too bad the food here sucks.

My fears materialise as the servings come to the table.  I own a Japanese yanagiba knife and I love using the single-bevel razor edge to cut see-through slices of vegetables; unfortunately, they use theirs to carve see-through slices of fish.  Look closely at the salmon and you can see the rice behind the flesh.





As I just said, sushi is supposed to be elegant; this teal blue plate looks plain cheap (the chip doesn’t help).  This isn’t attractive nor appetising.  I never thought I’d miss the simple but pretty garnishes; I even miss the tawdry plastic leaves.  This presentation looks worse than what Mel would serve out of his diner.

You can imagine what the food tastes like—it’s rice of course.  There’s so little fish in any of the rolls that the only taste I get is rice; I can’t even taste the normally pungent nori.  I delicately pull the pieces of fish out of the roll to sample them but alas, there isn’t enough to get a good sense.  The chopped scallop pellets are the size of boogers and for all I know, they could taste like boogers since there’s so little to sample and discern. 

Aside from the rice, the only thing that I can really taste is the sweetish sauce that’s squirted on all the rolls.  Being a sweet sauce, it goes well with items like eel, Japanese mushrooms, crab or shrimp.  It certainly doesn’t go with spicy salmon or spicy tuna, yet they indiscriminately sprayed it all over everything. 

Granted, $12.95 is a great price for all you can eat but gees, the food has to taste at least somewhere acceptable.  The sushi is an absolute write-off but at least the tempura has some redeeming qualities.  The batter tastes a tad chewy, which means that they’ve been out of the hot oil for a bit too long.  By contrast, the shrimps came out at just the right time.  The meat tastes moist and juicy, and they accompany (that same) sweet sauce nicely.  For $5.95, this is a pretty good bargain.




Especially in this age when Japanese restaurants sprout like shiitake mushrooms, there’s no reason to settle for substandard sushi; Magic Sushi 2’s maki sits two levels below substandard.  My phobia about all you can eat sushi has been robustly restored and I’m back to the adage of “you get what you pay for.”

** /5

This is a free product that I'm happy to bring to you.  If you enjoyed reading this, please consider clicking on the accompanying ads.  This is the only payment I receive for offering this public service.  Thank you as always for reading.



Magic Sushi 2 on Urbanspoon







Comments